
What is a good return on real estate investment? It depends on which return you measure. ROI, cap rate, cash-on-cash and total return answer different questions, so a "good" number on one is not comparable to another. For a market benchmark, large US institutional-grade properties in the NCREIF Property Index returned 5.2% before leverage and fees over the four quarters ending Q3 2026. Use benchmarks like this to judge whether a deal is pulling its weight.
Quick answer
Pick the metric first, then judge the number. Cap rate measures income against price. Cash-on-cash measures cash flow against your cash in. ROI and total return add appreciation over time.
Recent US benchmarks: NCREIF Property Index 5.2% total return for the four quarters ending Q3 2026; NCREIF residential 4.5% for the four quarters ending Q2 2026 (10-year average 5.0%). Returns are not guaranteed.
Sources: NCREIF NPI Q3 2026 press release; RCLCO summary of NCREIF Q2 2026 results.
Written by Alex Arguelles, CEO & Co-founder of Sell2Rent · Updated November 4, 2026
What does "return" mean in real estate?
Return is what an investment pays you relative to what you put in. In rental real estate it comes from two places: income (rent after operating expenses) and appreciation (the change in the property's value). Each metric below slices those two sources differently. For a deeper look at the two most-used metrics, read cap rate vs cash-on-cash return.
How are ROI, cap rate, cash-on-cash and total return different?
Four real estate return metrics: what each one tells you
| Metric | Formula | Best used for |
|---|---|---|
| Cap rate | Net operating income ÷ purchase price | Comparing properties on income, before financing |
| Cash-on-cash return | Annual pre-tax cash flow after debt ÷ total cash invested | Yearly cash yield on your own money, with financing |
| ROI | (Total gain − total cost) ÷ total cash invested | The full result of a deal when you sell |
| Total return | Income return + appreciation return, for a set period | Benchmarking against indexes like NCREIF or Nareit |
Net operating income is rent minus operating expenses, before mortgage payments. Formulas are standard industry definitions.
Cap rate: income against price
Cap rate ignores financing, so it lets you compare two properties on equal footing. A higher cap rate means more income per dollar of price, often with more risk or less expected growth.
Cash-on-cash return: cash flow against your cash
Cash-on-cash includes your mortgage payment. Leverage can raise it or lower it, depending on the loan rate compared with the property's yield. It does not include appreciation or principal paydown.
ROI and total return: the full picture
ROI looks at everything, start to finish, including purchase costs, repairs, financing and sale proceeds. Total return is the same idea measured over a set period, which is how indexes report performance.
What counts as a good return right now?
These are recent, published US benchmarks. They are unleveraged unless noted, so they are closest to a cap rate plus appreciation. Your leveraged cash-on-cash or ROI can be higher or lower.
US real estate return benchmarks: latest published figures
| Benchmark | Period | Total return |
|---|---|---|
| NCREIF Property Index, all property | 4 quarters ending Q3 2026 | 5.2% |
| NCREIF Property Index, all property | Q3 2026 (1.18% income + 0.22% appreciation) | 1.41% |
| NCREIF residential | 4 quarters ending Q2 2026 (4.4% income) | 4.5% |
| NCREIF residential, 10-year average | 10 years ending Q2 2026 | 5.0% |
| NCREIF apartment | 4 quarters ending Q2 2026 | 4.6% |
| NCREIF single-family rental | 4 quarters ending Q2 2026 (3.8% income, -1.5% appreciation) | 2.3% |
| FTSE Nareit All Equity REITs | Calendar year 2025 | 2.27% |
| FTSE Nareit Single Family Homes REITs | Calendar year 2025 | -10.24% |
Sources: NCREIF NPI Q3 2026 press release (Oct. 2026); RCLCO summary of NCREIF Q2 2026 results; Nareit REITWatch (April 2026). NCREIF figures are unleveraged and before fees.
What the benchmarks say about income vs appreciation
Most of the recent return has come from income, not price growth. In the Q3 2026 NCREIF index, income made up 1.18 points of the 1.41% quarterly return. Single-family rentals in the index earned a 3.8% income return over the four quarters ending Q2 2026, while values fell 1.5%.
Home prices are still rising, just slowly. The FHFA House Price Index rose 2.1% year over year in Q2 2026. HUD's national housing market summary reports the S&P Cotality Case-Shiller national index up 1.2% year over year in Q2 2026 and a median existing-home price of $430,500. That means a deal that leans on fast appreciation needs a closer look.
What vacancy means for your return
Vacancy cuts income directly. The Census Bureau reported a 7.6% national rental vacancy rate in Q3 2026, up from 7.1% in Q3 2025. A property that already has a signed lease in place removes the first vacancy period from your numbers. To stress-test a deal, see the numbers that make or break a real estate investment.
How do you judge whether a specific deal is good?
- Use one metric across every deal you compare. Do not compare one deal's cap rate with another's cash-on-cash return.
- Check the income side first. Recent benchmarks show income doing most of the work. Verify rent, expenses and lease terms.
- Be conservative on appreciation. Recent national price growth has been in the low single digits.
- Price in vacancy and repairs. Use local vacancy data and a repair reserve, even with a lease in place.
- Compare against a benchmark. Ask whether the deal beats the NCREIF residential return after your extra effort and risk.
How do sale-leaseback homes fit into return targets?
A sale-leaseback home comes with the former owner staying as the renter on a signed lease. That gives you income from day one and a resident who knows the home. Lease terms run from 1 month up to 5 years and vary by property. You can review the current lease before you buy. Rent and terms are in writing before you commit.
Sell2Rent connects investors with homeowners who want to sell and stay. We do not own the homes. See how investing with Sell2Rent works and the investor FAQ.
Looking for homes with income on day one? Set your buy box.
Joining the buyers list is free. Tell us where and what you buy, and we'll send matching off-market homes with a signed lease as they become available.
Lease terms run from 1 month up to 5 years and vary by property. You can review the current lease before you buy. Rent and terms are in writing before you commit. Returns are not guaranteed.Good return on real estate investment: frequently asked questions
What is a good return on real estate investment?
There is no single number. As a benchmark, the NCREIF Property Index returned 5.2% unleveraged over the four quarters ending Q3 2026, and residential returned 4.5% over the four quarters ending Q2 2026. Compare any deal on the same metric. Returns are not guaranteed.
What is the difference between ROI and cap rate?
Cap rate is net operating income divided by the purchase price, with no financing. ROI is your total gain divided by the total cash you put in, and it includes financing, costs and appreciation.
What is cash-on-cash return?
Cash-on-cash return is the yearly cash flow after debt payments divided by the cash you invested. It shows the cash yield on your own money in a given year.
What is total return in real estate?
Total return is income plus the change in value over a period. NCREIF reports it as an income return plus an appreciation return. In Q3 2026 that was 1.18% income plus 0.22% appreciation, for 1.41% total.
How do single-family rentals compare with other real estate?
In the NCREIF index, single-family rentals returned 2.3% over the four quarters ending Q2 2026, made up of 3.8% income and -1.5% appreciation. Apartments returned 4.6% over the same period.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment, legal or tax advice. Returns vary by property, market and financing. Returns are not guaranteed. Past index performance does not predict future results. Consider talking with a licensed attorney, tax professional and financial professional before you invest.
Sell2Rent is not the purchaser. We connect sellers with investors. With Sell2Rent, a buy-back option is not offered. Failure to pay rent could result in eviction. Sell2Rent is not a real estate brokerage or a qualified financial professional. Sell2Rent may work with partners who provide related services, and in some cases, Sell2Rent may receive compensation for referrals.
Sources
- NCREIF, NCREIF Property Index Q3 2026 press release, October 2026
- NCREIF, NPI Snapshot Report, Q2 2026, 2026
- RCLCO, Q2 2026 NCREIF Results Summary, August 2026
- Nareit, REITWatch, April 2026 (2025 total returns), April 2026
- Federal Housing Finance Agency, House Price Index, Q2 2026, August 25, 2026
- U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, National Housing Market Summary, 2nd Quarter 2026, 2026
- U.S. Census Bureau, Housing Vacancies and Homeownership, Q3 2026, October 28, 2026


